Vintage Carriage Light Streetlights

A noticeable trend in our area is the use of vintage carriage lights as streetlights. These examples can be seen at Legacy Park, in Mechanicsburg, and Sinclair Park, in Monroe Township, on the west side of Mechanicsburg.

An analysis of the illumination pattern, directionality and efficiency of vintage carriage lighting follows. A little bit of research also led into some finds and discussion about proper pedestrian crossing lighting.

What I found was as expected. Literally, 3/4 or more of the light goes out the sides, directed horizontally. Only about 1/4 or less of the light is directed downward. There is some upward cutoff but because of the higher CCT chosen for these lights, a lot of the light is scattered upwards, creating a mini-skyglow dome over the new development that can be seen from blocks away.

A main issue with designing safe pedestrian lighting is the competition with the ambient light level and properly contrasting pedestrians so they can be seen and even highlighted. In this case, about 4 lux was available just outside of the shadow caused by the base of the the light fixture (shown in the picture on the right). Even less light was in an approximate 10′ radius around the light pole. At the same time, about 25 lux, as high as I could reach, was directed horizontally into the new homes, first and second stories, along the street.

In essence, the lighting choice of vintage carriage street lights in this new development disregards pedestrian safety by illuminating everything else at 4 times the level of the pedestrians. Best practice for pedestrian safety is approximately 10 lux above the ambient lighting level. Improper lighting choice by the developers has turned this lighting scheme upside down from what it should be.

In addition, people buying the new homes will be presented with the problem of high CCT street lights, on all night long and illuminating the inside of their homes at night. Per research, 5 lux, is the benchmark level for human circadian disruption. The 25 lux light level into the homes is well above this known threshold where impacts to human health occur.

In the case of Legacy Park, developers have chosen to ignore the recommendations of both the medical professionals and environmentalist in choosing a high CCT light source. I personally have not checked Sinclair Park for spectrum or CCT. While CCT is not a good absolute, 3000K is the maximum CCT that should be used. Read that, 3000K is not the standard, it’s the maximum CCT.

As far as efficiency goes, the carriage lights are LED, but with the misdirected lighting wasting 3/4 of the light and energy, these lights as ‘efficient street lighting’ get the elimination buzzer. Remember, we are all paying the electric bill.

The application of vintage carriage style lights as street lighting is simply the wrong luminaire for the application. Carriage lights as street lights create similar pitfalls and problems as vintage acorn lighting previously discussed in my blog.

I believe, in the first Star Wars, Jedi Obi-Wan Kenobi, told the storm troopers looking for Luke and the droids, These aren’t the lights you want…

Light well and prosper…

Mark

Appalachian Trail and Pipelines

Let’s take a short rabbit trail to a serious situation the Appalachian Trail is facing. Pipelines scar the landscape and pose a high risk of contaminating whatever environment they cut through. The Appalachian Trail is there to preserve a wild experience and is open to all. Pipeline operators see the Trail as an obstacle to their profit at all costs. Please read this article and stand with the Appalachian Trail and the ATC to preserve the Trail corridor for future generations.

Will the Appalachian Trail Stop an $8 Billion Pipeline?

Please head over to the ATC’s site to support and encourage them in opposing the pipelines crossing the trail corridor. www.appalachiantrail.org

While you are there, putting in a plug for saving the night, check out Go Dark – A Wild East Story

Light Well and Prosper,

Mark

Lament for the Stars

Lament for the Stars, my new single, is submitted for release. If all goes well, it will soon be available for streaming on all the major music providers, like AppleMusic, Spotify, Pandora, Tidal, etc.

What moves me, usually ends up coming out through my musical expression. Light pollution is deeply unsettling to me, especially when the root problems are so easily resolved. Outside lighting is done so haphazardly and carelessly these days. A good design and correct implementation is extremely rare and hard to find. There can be no doubt, improperly implemented lighting wastes huge amounts of energy and money. No doubt, the wrong spectrum at the wrong time of day WILL cause multiple disruptions in the human body. Most of those disruptions and suppressions put everyone exposed to higher risks for chronic diseases and cancers.

Careless implementation, poorly chosen and designed lighting devices, especially those of higher CCT and SPD’s with higher 400-500nm content will not only cause higher risks and problems for humans but also for every other living creature on earth. Whole ecosystems are being destroyed and native species are disappearing while outside lighting expands to light empty parking lots, streets and empty buildings at unimaginable and wasteful levels.

You see, light and dark are powerful orchestrators, arrangers, and conductors for all ecosystems and creatures on Earth. What has taken eons of time to set in place is being destroyed by man in a very short time. The scourge of light pollution is slowly and nefariously erasing the natural beauty all around us, reducing our night sky and our daylight wonders into monochromatic emptiness. Between wasteful energy practices and disruption of the natural world, light pollution may very well bring about man’s eventual demise.

Psalm 19 is one of my favorite psalms. It’s the one where the stars pour forth the knowledge of God in a language that man has not understood. Right now, we are trading the beauty of the night sky for a milky white, sickly looking sky where not a single star is visible. It’s not pretty or beautiful although some would say it is. Maybe, they just have never gone outside their houses at night and looked up.

The night sky is so, so worth saving. Check out International Dark Sky Assn for more information. Also, please check out the Wolf Conservation Center. Wolves are so worth saving, too. They sang some very nice harmonies in my song! Please consider joining or donating to either the IDA or the Wolf Conservation Center.

Light well and prosper

Mark

Faith, Music, and Lighting

A collision of music and light

At historic RCA Studios in Nashville are some curious lights. They were historic mood setters for Elvis and his band. In one song, Elvis had the lights turned out and the musicians tracked the song in total darkness. At the end of the song, Elvis hit his head on the vocal mic. It’s in the recording if you listen!

In my own recording studio, I use Philips Hue LED lighting to set the mood when I record. The Hue lights provide beautiful colors and effects easily and adjust to whatever light level required. In addition, lava lamps, LED candle pillars, pilot lights and VU meters, and a star globe provide additional lighting, all to support the creative recording process. One time, I recorded a vocal in almost total darkness to get the feeling of being with a person in prison and how that would feel. Light is a tool for me. It can help stir imagination and give expressive performances.

Playing music live, recording and songwriting are part of me. For many years, my whole life has been immersed in music and production. Eventually, subjects that matter deeply to me are expressed through music. My faith is expressed through writing and playing music used in worship. In addition, my worldview on conservation and taking care of the earth is expressed through the language of music. Currently, complex theatrical style lighting is often used in the congregational worship setting, and certainly so in concert settings. Light, music, and musicians have a long relationship.

Faith, Music and the Loss of the Stars

As expected, topics and passion for things that are important to me eventually do show up in my songwriting. My worldview is expressed through music. I deeply care about the subject matter I sing about and write about here.

Over the last couple of weeks, a new song took shape and is called Lament for the Stars. It reflects my deep sadness over the creeping loss of the stars and night sky. It happed so slowly not many people noticed. In my new soon to be released song, my faith, my concern for conservation and preservation, and my music all collide. I will update my blog and provide links when the song is released in the next few days.

Lament for the Stars
Words and Music by Mark Grosz, Lil Wolf Productions c2020

I couldn’t see my stars tonight,
Someone has painted light across the sky.
At first it didn’t matter 'till I realized,
The paint got in my eye

It’s all about commerce.
It’s all about making a buck.
No matter what it does,
No matter who it harms.
It’s all about commerce.
It’s all about lightin’ up.
No matter what it does,
No matter who it harms.

Butterflies and fireflies,
The beauty of the night is so passé .
And who would think the loss of night,
Should cause us pause,
Such blindness whose mistake?

Beauty was in the eye of the beholder.

– Mark

Request: Globe at Night Campaign

⭐️ Please take a little time and submit an observation during the dates for February and March! ✨

Globe at Night is both cool citizen science and STEM. Observations are easy and will lead to kids to be curious about the night sky, stars, and a lot of other subjects. Print off a couple of the charts and head outside with a red night vision saving flashlight and see which chart matches the number of stars you can see in the constellation. The webapp is easy to use, contains no identifying data other than your observation location. You will be participating as data input for valid science research. It takes only a few minutes to do! Go outside! The stars are waiting for you!

Globe at Night

Globe at Night Campaign Dates and Constellations

Globe at Night Webapp

Easy as 𝛑

Check your observation location is correct, check the box under the map. Click on the chart that looks like the stars you can see from your location. Click on the sky condition choice. Enter any location or sky condition comments you might have. If you have a Sky Quality Meter, you can also take a reading. Enter the reading and the serial number of your unit. Hit Submit!

Mark

Where Have the Fireflies Gone?

And are we next on the list?

With the current interest in the media about fireflies and the stress light pollution from artificial light at night sources, I’ve collected a number of articles and research. Check out the Environmental section of my Resources Page for the articles, including a BBC Radio-cast documentary with people from Karachi, Pakistan. In one generation, the fireflies are gone, even from their expected habitats. Children are told stories and poems, and culture is informed by the writings and fables about fireflies. Unfortunately, none of the children in and around Karachi, Pakistan will ever actually see one. They are gone. This follows the unnatural negative effects of artificial lighting on an entire species. Note the lifestyle change of the people commented on by the people interviewed and that there is little hope for going back. Is that what we want in the US? I don’t believe that is progress. Very sad.

Maybe this summer, when the sun goes down, like the guests on the BBC Radio broadcast, maybe we can just go outside, sleep under the stars, if we can still find them, and hope to see some fireflies while we still can.

The natural world is so much more beautiful and complex than anything created by the hand of man. Even Leonardo da Vinci was an amateur compared to the hand of nature. Thomas Edison’s light is nothing compared to that of the stars, night skies and fireflies.

Mark

Light Shields, Myth or Fact?

A Lighting Experiment

One of my favorite TV shows was MythBusters. Using hands-on experiments to prove what is true or false is fun and informative. My last post showed the difference between shielded and unshielded light, and the results are true for ANY light source or fixture. The difference in the amount of light available at the surface level, for the same amount of light produced by the source, was very discernable but not quantified. This morning, I redid the experiment using a light meter. The numbers show absolute proof, a proper shield on your light is extremely valuable. Myth or Fact? This one is FACT.

Without Shield

As you can see, this table lamp is acting just like vintage lighting, with the shadow at the bottom and most of the light going up and out to the sides. The majority of the light being produced by the source is unusable for the purpose of the light’s primary task. You would have to increase the level of the light many times to get enough light to meet the required specifications on the surface. Note the light is producing well over 400 lux. Only about 25% of the light is directed downward, where it is required.

With Shield

The light level with the shield installed. The meter stayed in the same place. As you can plainly see, with the shield in place, 100% of the light level produced by the light source is being directed downward to the working surface where the light is actually needed. Some of the light is actually lost up through the hole at the top of the lampshade. Full shields on outside lighting would not allow upward light to be lost, reflecting it back down, so the efficiency results would be even greater.

The value of using shields with lighting

  • Light from the source is correctly directed towards the surface onto the primary task surface.
  • Light is redirected away from where the light is not needed or wanted
  • With shields the light becomes many times more efficient, providing the specified light level at a much lower overall light and energy level. Same light level at much less cost.
  • Shields save energy and money. More usable light can be produced from a fraction of light energy and electrical energy
  • Using shields will reduce ‘artificial light at night’ exposure to people and the environment.
  • Using shields to properly direct light and reduce the source level will reduce skyglow and light pollution

When light is controlled and directed properly negative attributes like glare and light trespass are eliminated or greatly reduced. At the same time, a properly shielded light source will produce more usable light to the task and result in a higher efficacy light source. The specified light level for a task surface can be reached at a much lower light and electrical energy level. In my experiment, the light is almost 4 times more efficient with the shield in place. That’s 400% folks.

LED lighting’s efficiency is great BUT not if you waste almost all of it. If light levels have to be increased to compensate for deficient luminaire shielding design, nothing is saved. In fact, in this case, it is LED’s efficacy that is a myth. It may actually cost more to provide the same amount of light provided by previous technologies, like HPS. Whatever the type of light source, properly designed and implemented shielding WILL save money and will greatly increase the efficacy of the light source.

Mark

Vintage Acorn Streetlights Analyzed

The problem

Carlisle had a very nice Ice Fest event downtown this weekend. Ice carvings by local artists were on display throughout the downtown Carlisle streets and the shops and restaurants were buzzing with activity. While the event and it’s family friendly atmosphere was really a fun time, it gave me a chance to observe and consider Carlisle’s vintage style acorn lights so common to many downtowns in our area.

Vintage acorn lights capture the look of years gone past in downtown shopping areas and they look cool. Unfortunately, vintage acorn style light fixtures are the poster children for poor light distribution and are the most wasteful lighting type available. Their circular base at the bottom of the glass envelope blocks light from lighting the sidewalk and street underneath. The height of the pole and size of the base determine the size of the shadow underneath the light fixture. The lack of substantial lighting on the walks is evident in the photos, along with the excessive levels on the walls of the buildings. The main purpose of these lights was to light the buildings so people could see the businesses and business signage. They are not useful or the proper luminaires for lighting sidewalks or streets. Most models are also the worst kind of lighting to use if you are concerned about light pollution and energy waste.

Entirely missing the purpose of street lighting, acorn style lighting mainly illuminates people’s first or second floor dwellings. Even worse, the poor light distribution on the walks and street require the light level to be increased to make up for the poor directional light control from the acorn light envelope. Not only is light wasted, energy is wasted. While LEDs, are more energy efficient in a one to one comparison, still over 70% of the light and therefore the energy is wasted. A simple internal reflector inside the glass envelope would reduce the energy required to run whatever light source you choose by 2/3rd’s or more, and give you the same amount of light on the street and walks as is there currently.

One of the acorn lights pictured is a high CCT LED. The LED acorn lamp is lighting up the front of someone’s house and living spaces in light of the worst spectrum for human health you can use.

Problem Summary
  • poor light distribution and control
  • large shadow underneath due to base
  • requires more energy and higher light levels to reach required light levels on street and sidewalks, wastes 2/3rd’s of the produced light
  • light people’s homes, inside and out
  • worst source of upward light and cause of light pollution unless shielded on top
  • worst type of light for controlling light trespass into homes and minimizing human health effects (all spectra of light can cause human health issues and certain spectra carries higher risks than others)

One Potential Solution

Please note Carlisle’s vintage acorn lights do have one positive feature. I believe they are almost full cutoff due to the uplight blocking top shield. This would stop the majority of light from going up. I don’t believe the top shield is reflective or the light level on the walks would be much better. The majority of the light from these lights still is out to the side rather than down, where the task is. Maybe the look of lights is considered first, instead of a definition of what the purpose of the light is and what task it is supposed to illuminate.

In searching for internal shields to use with the vintage acorn lights, I ran across this simple shield. I am sure there are other versions of this by other companies. This is just one I found that could maybe provide a solution to the problems associated with the vintage acorn lights

  • keep the vintage look, preserve the investment in the street lighting fixtures
  • direct the light produced by the luminaire to where it is needed
  • provide relief to the residents who live in the downtown buildings
  • save energy and money
  • better for the environment and people’s health

Dark Sky Reflector for Large Acorn Globe Light

Comments?

It would be great to hear from anyone who has experience with adding internal shields to existing vintage acorn lighting, especially if it concerned LED retrofits.

Mark

Shady Deals

Putting your shades on

I believe professional lighting makes things way, way too complex. Common sense can lead to easy solutions for many lighting problems. As they say, sometimes, one can’t see the forest for the trees.

Table lamps are a common element at everyone’s house. Initially, light bulbs were clear. As the filiments got brighter, they weren’t pleasant to look at because of the bright light source intensity. The lighting industry started frosting the inside of the bulb to spread the emission from the filament over a larger surface area which also made the light from the bulb more consistent.

Because of the glare from the lamp, people put shades over the light. This is to remove the direct glare from our eyes and to direct the light to where we want it. The inside of the shade is reflective, so it also takes light that would be wasted and directs it to where it is needed. This is a common solution for our home lighting.

A light like in leftmost picture, a lamp without a shade, is putting less than 30% of the light where it is needed. In the picture on the right, the same lamp, sporting a nice shade to properly direct the light, 90% of the light is directed downward to the required task area and primary purpose. The level of the light can be reduced by 2/3 and get the same amount of ‘real’ task light by using proper shielding.

So why do we do outside lighting like this?

In the above picture, 70% of the light and the energy used to produce it is wasted. The lights at these commercial sites are at this level all night, with no one there. Is this good common sense?

In this case, even if they left it on all night long, they could save 70% of the electric bill and have the exact same amount of light on their product as they have now. At the same time, the owners would reduce their carbon footprint and reduce the ecological impact of their lighting by a significant amount. Using adaptive lighting to reduce levels or even turn most lighting off after hours would yield significant savings and therefore increase profit. This is common sense, isn’t it?

Mark

Good Lighting Starts at Home

It’s important to know. Good lighting practices begin at home. I’ve often suggested for designers and installers to walk away from their work, over into the dark and look back on their lighting. For the benefit of your neighbors, when implementing outside lighting for your home, walk across the street or go to the adjoining darker area and look back at your property. Only dark adapted eyes will give you a proper perspective on how your lighting affects other people’s properties and lives.

While streetlights and building/parking lot lighting are the major players in the light pollution/energy waste problem, we can all help with light pollution by taking a look at our own residential lighting. It’s like having your own garden and growing your own vegetables. Satisfaction can be found when you do a good job with your own outside residential lighting.

Need some help? Assess your own residential lighting design by following this flowchart from International Dark Sky Association. See if you can improve your residential lighting to be safer and more beautiful, and be more energy efficient to boot! Be a responsible lighter!

Click to access Home-Lighting-Assessment-Print.pdf

Mark